France’s data-protection authority has opened a short evidence exercise on how organisations are implementing its rules for tracking pixels embedded in email.
The CNIL is asking message senders and technology providers to submit practical, preferably quantified evidence by 3 December. It wants to understand compliance costs, changes in audience-measurement and personalisation practices, and alternatives developed since its April recommendation took effect.
That recommendation requires consent for many tracking uses, while recognising narrow exemptions where a pixel is strictly necessary for purposes such as deliverability or user-centred security. A deliverability exemption does not extend to collecting opening times or other data beyond what is necessary. The CNIL has also said that anonymising extra data after collection does not cure an over-broad initial collection.
Implementation was phased. New customer relationships were expected to comply from the outset. For email addresses already held when the recommendation was published, senders were given a period to provide clear information and a simple opportunity to object.
The exercise is not a suspension of those rules. The regulator says it will use the evidence to assess practical effects, identify difficulties and good practices, and refine its support for organisations.

