The Court of Justice of the European Union has declined to examine questions about Malta’s restrictions on enforcing foreign gambling judgments, finding that the Austrian reference did not arise from a dispute that required an answer on EU law.
Spielerschutz Sigma finances Austrian claims by players seeking repayment of losses from online operators licensed in Malta but not in Austria. After Malta amended its law in 2023 to restrict actions and foreign judgments against licensed operators, the company obtained advice that the amendment was manifestly incompatible with EU law. A Maltese court later refused enforcement of an Austrian judgment.
The current case was not an enforcement challenge. It was a damages claim in Vienna against the legal adviser, alleging that the advice had been wrong. The Austrian Commercial Court asked the EU court to rule on the Maltese legislation.
In its 19 November judgment, the Court declared the reference inadmissible. It said a preliminary ruling must be objectively necessary to decide the national dispute and supported by a real, concrete connection to the EU provisions at issue. A hypothetical or speculative connection is insufficient. The ruling is final on admissibility but leaves the underlying compatibility of the Maltese law unresolved.

