Azerbaijan violated the liberty and assembly rights of three men who were taken into custody during peaceful demonstrations in Baku without their arrests being formally recorded, the European Court of Human Rights has held.
The joined applications were brought by Idris Bayram oglu Amiraslan, Aziz Iltifat oglu Mamiyev and Tofig Rashid oglu Yagublu. Their cases concerned separate demonstrations relating to the detention of a political figure and proposed changes affecting political parties. Each man said he was taken to a police station, held for several hours and released without any official record of the deprivation of liberty.
In its 17 November Chamber judgment, the Court found violations of Article 5(1) of the European Convention on Human Rights. An arrest or detention cannot be placed outside the protections of the Convention merely by leaving it undocumented. The absence of a formal record also deprived the applicants of the safeguards that ordinarily accompany a lawful detention.
The Court separately found violations of Article 11. The gatherings were peaceful, and the authorities had not shown that taking the applicants away and holding them was a necessary and proportionate interference with freedom of assembly. The judgment treats the police action as a restriction on participation in the demonstrations, even though the confinement lasted only hours and did not lead to a recorded prosecution.
The Court awarded non-pecuniary compensation under Article 41. The judgment is a Chamber ruling and is not yet final: under Article 44(2), it will become final after the Convention’s prescribed period unless a party seeks referral to the Grand Chamber and the request is accepted.
The official case record for Amiraslan and Others v Azerbaijan contains the judgment and procedural details.

