In a resounding verdict echoing across the chambers of justice, the Supreme Court has wielded its authority to demand a fundamental reassessment of state practices regarding the profiling of individuals in ‘History Sheets’, a practice often marred by the stain of caste bias and social disadvantage.
With a keen eye on rectifying systemic injustices, the apex court, invoking its suo moto powers, has issued a clarion call to all States and Union Territories, urging them to reevaluate their protocols concerning the inclusion of innocent individuals in these historical records. Such inclusion, based solely on caste or socio-economic background, has long been a blight on the fabric of justice, perpetuating stereotypes and perpetrating untold injustices against marginalized communities.
Citing disturbing patterns reminiscent of colonial-era prejudices, the Bench, led by Justices Surya Kant and KV Viswanathan, highlighted the egregious nature of these discriminatory practices. The Court’s assertion, grounded in constitutional principles, underscores the intrinsic value of human dignity enshrined in Article 21, casting a glaring light on the violation of this sacred right through the arbitrary inclusion of individuals in ‘History Sheets’.
“We cannot turn a blind eye to the plight of innocent individuals who find themselves ensnared in the web of prejudice solely due to their social standing,” remarked the Court, emphasizing the need for proactive measures to shield vulnerable communities from the scourge of discriminatory targeting.
Central to the Court’s pronouncement is the recognition of the insidious impact of preconceived notions, relegating innocent individuals to the shadows of society, deprived of their right to a life of dignity and respect. This acknowledgment serves as a clarion call for systemic reform, urging State Governments to enact preventive measures that safeguard the rights of all citizens, irrespective of their background.
The landmark verdict, arising from the plea of AAP MLA Amanatullah Khan, further underscores the imperative of judicial oversight in scrutinizing the contents of ‘History Sheets’. The Court’s rebuke of the Delhi Police’s characterization of Khan, coupled with directives for the exclusion of innocent family members from such records, signals a watershed moment in the annals of justice.
Furthermore, the Court’s endorsement of a periodic audit mechanism, coupled with the directive for States to emulate the ‘Delhi Model’, heralds a new era of accountability and transparency in law enforcement practices. By placing the onus on authorities to ensure the integrity of historical records, the Court has paved the way for a more equitable and just society.
As the echoes of this historic judgment reverberate, it serves as a beacon of hope for countless individuals ensnared in the coils of caste-based profiling. With the scales of justice recalibrated, a new dawn emerges, promising equality, dignity, and the restoration of fundamental rights for all.
