The US Senate has confirmed Daniel Domenico, a federal judge appointed during Donald Trump’s first presidential term, to serve on a powerful appeals court, marking another step in the Republican effort to reshape the federal judiciary before Democrats take control of the chamber.
The Republican-controlled Senate approved Domenico’s elevation on Monday through a 51-46 vote. He will join the Denver-based 10th US Circuit Court of Appeals, which handles appeals originating from Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Utah and Wyoming.
Domenico currently serves as a US District Judge in Colorado and was originally appointed to the federal bench by Trump during his first term.
His confirmation leaves three other appeals court nominees awaiting Senate approval during the remaining weeks of Republican control.
Republicans accelerate judicial appointments
The confirmation comes amid an intensified push by the White House to secure judicial appointments before the incoming political balance of the Senate changes.
Republicans suffered setbacks in the November 3 midterm elections, prompting efforts to move forward with pending nominations while they still hold control of the chamber.
The administration is seeking confirmation for 22 additional judicial nominees in the final weeks of the current Senate session.
Another nominee, US District Judge Anna St. John of Louisiana, is also moving closer to confirmation. Trump has nominated her to the 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals, based in New Orleans.
However, not every nomination has progressed smoothly.
Texas nomination encounters resistance
Two other nominees are facing difficulties because their home-state senators have not extended the support needed to advance their nominations.
One of them is T. Elliot Gaiser, who heads the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel. Trump nominated him for a federal judgeship in Dallas, although Gaiser is originally from Ohio.
Texas Republican Senator John Cornyn has yet to commit to providing the required blue slip, a procedural approval traditionally sought from senators representing the state where a judicial vacancy exists.
An aide to Cornyn said on Monday that the senator had instead recommended Steve Fahey, a former federal prosecutor, as an alternative candidate.
Domenico’s nomination, by contrast, encountered considerably fewer obstacles.
Replacing a longtime 10th Circuit judge
Domenico will fill the seat being vacated by US Circuit Judge Timothy Tymkovich, who announced in February that he intended to step away from active judicial service.
The two judges have a professional connection dating back to Domenico’s earlier career, when he worked as a law clerk for Tymkovich.
Despite Domenico’s appointment, Democratic-appointed judges continue to hold a 7-5 majority on the 10th Circuit.
Earlier rulings draw Democratic criticism
Domenico’s judicial record became a central issue during the confirmation debate, particularly his decisions involving religious institutions, abortion-related treatment and immigration detention.
In 2023, he ruled against Colorado’s attempt to exclude a Christian private school from a publicly funded universal preschool programme because of its religious position on LGBTQ+ issues.
In another decision that year, he blocked enforcement of a Colorado law prohibiting so-called abortion reversal treatment offered by a Catholic medical centre.
Democrats also questioned his approach to immigration detention, arguing that his decisions placed him outside the mainstream of federal district court judges.
Domenico had rejected several challenges to the Trump administration’s policy of keeping certain immigrants in mandatory detention without allowing them to seek release through bond hearings.
Defending his interpretation, Domenico maintained that his position was consistent with decisions issued by two federal appeals courts.
He also pointed to his subsequent actions after the 10th Circuit rejected the administration’s interpretation in June. Following that ruling, he said he complied with the appellate court’s decision and directed the administration to explain why detained migrants should not be released or provided an opportunity for a bond hearing before an immigration judge.
The broader legal dispute over mandatory immigration detention is now before the US Supreme Court.
Domenico’s elevation adds another Trump-appointed judge to the federal appellate judiciary, while the administration continues its effort to secure additional judicial confirmations before the Senate’s political control changes.

