A federal judge has allowed most of US President Donald Trump’s $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times and publisher Penguin Random House to proceed, rejecting attempts to have the entire case thrown out.
The ruling allows Trump to continue pursuing allegations that the newspaper and its journalists published damaging and misleading accounts of his business career and personal history in an effort to undermine his 2024 presidential campaign.
US District Judge Steven Merryday, sitting in Tampa, Florida, dismissed two claims but concluded that other parts of Trump’s complaint contained sufficiently plausible allegations to survive the initial legal challenge.
The lawsuit targets two New York Times articles and a book written by the newspaper’s journalists Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner. Trump has sought at least $15 billion in damages, accusing the defendants of publishing statements that were false, malicious and defamatory.
Court identifies claims that can proceed
In examining the complaint, Judge Merryday found that allegations concerning statements in an article by journalist Peter Baker and the book co-authored by Craig and Buettner could move forward.
The judge said Trump’s complaint plausibly alleged that certain assertions accusing him of planning and carrying out complex crimes were based on incomplete or limited information.
However, the court dismissed Trump’s claims relating to a separate New York Times article concerning his involvement in the reality television programme The Apprentice.
The lawsuit also challenges more than two dozen statements drawn from the newspaper’s reporting and the book titled Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father’s Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success.
The disputed material addresses several aspects of Trump’s background, including his inheritance from his father, his business ventures, his upbringing in New York and the development of his television career.
Newspaper and publisher reject allegations
The New York Times and Penguin Random House had urged the court to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing that Trump’s complaint failed to establish how the disputed statements amounted to defamation.
Their legal arguments also maintained that several statements represented subjective opinions rather than objectively verifiable claims that could form the basis of a defamation action.
A spokesperson for The New York Times described the lawsuit as legally baseless and characterised it as an attack on independent journalism and press freedom.
Penguin Random House said it continued to stand behind the book and its authors, expressing confidence that the case would ultimately be dismissed.
Trump’s legal team welcomed the decision, arguing that the defendants would now have to respond to allegations of intentional and malicious defamation.
Trump’s wider legal campaign against media organisations
The latest decision comes amid Trump’s broader legal campaign against media companies over coverage he considers inaccurate or damaging.
Since 2024, the president has brought multiple lawsuits accusing news organisations of defamation or misleading reporting. Critics have raised concerns that such litigation could place pressure on media organisations and undermine press freedom.
Just a week before the latest ruling, another federal judge allowed Trump’s defamation lawsuit against the BBC over an edited video clip to proceed. The British broadcaster has denied liability.
The latest decision does not establish that The New York Times or Penguin Random House defamed Trump. It means only that the surviving allegations have cleared an initial procedural hurdle and can continue through the legal process.
The case now moves into its next stage, where the defendants will have to address the claims that remain before the court.

