Skip to content
Thursday, November 19, 2026
Global legal news — updated throughout the day
Independent · Global
COURT CAST
Law · Courts · Power · Across the World
Today’s Edition — 23 verified developments across 15 jurisdictions
United States · Courts

Minnesota’s Abortion Laws Face Unusual Constitutional Challenge Before US Appeals Court

A federal appeals court is considering an unusual legal challenge to Minnesota’s abortion framework, with anti-abortion organisations arguing that the state’s decision to permit abortions throughout pregnancy violates constitutional protections and undermines a pregnant woman’s relationship with her unborn child.

A three-judge panel of the 8th US Circuit Court of Appeals heard arguments on Wednesday in an appeal seeking to revive a lawsuit dismissed by a lower court in 2025.

The case was brought by two anti-abortion pregnancy centres, their medical directors and the National Institute of Family and Life Advocates. They are challenging Minnesota’s abortion policies, which allow the procedure at any stage of pregnancy without mandatory waiting periods, counselling sessions, ultrasound examinations or similar requirements imposed by some other states.

The plaintiffs argue that these policies violate the Due Process Clause of the 14th Amendment to the US Constitution by allowing pregnancies to be terminated without adequate legal safeguards.

Plaintiffs argue mothers’ constitutional rights are being overlooked

Representing the challengers, attorney Derek Cassidy told the appeals court that Minnesota’s legal framework could leave pregnant women vulnerable to pressure to undergo abortions without meaningful procedural protections.

He argued that the state’s policies interfere with what the plaintiffs describe as a constitutionally protected relationship between a mother and her unborn child.

Cassidy maintained that the authority of states to regulate abortion does not give them unrestricted power to permit the procedure without safeguards.

The lawsuit names Minnesota officials, abortion providers, including two Planned Parenthood affiliates, and other state authorities as defendants.

State argues dispute belongs in the political process

Minnesota has defended the dismissal of the case, describing the plaintiffs’ arguments as a disagreement with the state’s abortion policy rather than a valid constitutional claim.

Margaret Jacot, representing the Minnesota Attorney General’s Office, told the appeals court that those opposing the state’s approach should pursue legislative changes or seek a constitutional amendment instead of asking federal judges to intervene.

She argued that the federal courts were not the appropriate forum for resolving what amounted to a policy dispute.

Appeals judges question the impact of Supreme Court ruling

The appeals panel did not indicate how it might ultimately decide the case, although the judges raised questions about the constitutional arguments presented by the challengers.

Circuit Judge Steven Colloton focused on the US Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which overturned the landmark Roe v. Wade ruling and removed the nationwide constitutional protection for abortion.

The Dobbs decision returned substantial authority over abortion regulation to individual states.

Colloton questioned how the plaintiffs could establish their proposed constitutional restrictions in light of the Supreme Court’s ruling, which left states with broad discretion over abortion policy.

Cassidy responded that state authority to regulate abortion does not mean governments can permit the procedure without appropriate restrictions or protections.

The appeals panel also includes Circuit Judges Bobby Shepherd and Jane Kelly.

Lower court previously rejected the lawsuit

US District Judge Nancy Ellen Brasel, appointed by Trump, dismissed the lawsuit in 2025, identifying several fundamental problems with the complaint.

Among other concerns, she said the plaintiffs had failed to clearly identify the specific Minnesota laws they were challenging and had not adequately established their legal standing to bring the case.

The appeal seeks to overcome those deficiencies and secure another opportunity to pursue the constitutional claims.

A different direction in post-Dobbs abortion litigation

The case stands apart from much of the abortion-related litigation that has followed the Supreme Court’s reversal of Roe v. Wade.

Most major legal disputes since 2022 have involved challenges to abortion bans and restrictions introduced by Republican-led states, as well as efforts to restrict access to the abortion medication mifepristone.

This lawsuit takes the opposite approach by challenging a state policy that allows relatively broad access to abortion.

The dispute, Women’s Life Care Center v. Ellison, is pending before the 8th US Circuit Court of Appeals under case number 25-2905.

The appeals court’s eventual ruling will determine whether the plaintiffs can revive their challenge and continue pursuing their argument that Minnesota’s abortion framework violates constitutional protections.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
The Court Cast Research Library

News on the surface. Primary law underneath.

Search judgments, official documents, oral arguments and the accumulated record behind the daily edition.

Oral arguments
84,000+

A deep searchable record of court proceedings.

Explore
Global

Judgments · Documents · Practice Notes · Jurisdictions · Events

Scroll to Top