Elon Musk’s artificial intelligence company, xAI, is seeking to prevent California from enforcing a law that requires AI developers to reveal details about the datasets used to train their systems, arguing that the disclosure requirements threaten constitutional protections and expose valuable commercial secrets.
The dispute reached the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco on Wednesday, where a three-judge panel examined xAI’s request to block the legislation. Although the judges appeared unconvinced by the company’s broad constitutional challenge, they also raised concerns about how much information the state could legally demand from AI developers.
The legislation, signed by California Governor Gavin Newsom in September 2024, requires companies developing generative AI systems to publish summaries of the datasets used to train their models.
The law took effect on January 1 as part of California’s wider effort to introduce greater transparency and accountability into the rapidly expanding AI industry.
xAI argues disclosure rules threaten trade secrets
xAI filed its lawsuit against California last year, claiming the legislation violates the free-speech protections guaranteed by the First Amendment of the US Constitution.
The company also argues that forcing AI developers to disclose information about their training datasets could reveal commercially sensitive details about how their models are developed.
Seeking an immediate halt to the law, xAI asked the courts to prevent its enforcement while the wider constitutional challenge proceeds.
However, its initial attempt failed in March, when US District Judge Jesus Bernal in Los Angeles refused to grant a preliminary injunction.
Bernal concluded that xAI had not demonstrated, at that early stage of the proceedings, that it was likely to establish that the legislation was unconstitutional.
The company subsequently took its challenge to the 9th Circuit.
Judges question the company’s constitutional argument
During Wednesday’s hearing, the appeals court appeared receptive to parts of the reasoning behind the lower court’s decision.
US Circuit Judge Johnnie Rawlinson questioned whether requiring companies to provide information about their AI training material could reasonably be considered a legitimate government request.
She suggested that citizens have a reasonable interest in understanding what information goes into the AI systems they use.
The questioning placed pressure on xAI’s argument that the disclosure requirement itself violates free-speech protections.
However, the judges did not limit their scrutiny to the company’s position.
California also faces questions over disclosure limits
US Circuit Judge Danielle Forrest raised a separate concern about the potential scope of the law, asking how far California could go in demanding information from AI companies.
Her questioning focused on whether the legislation could effectively allow the government to demand an unlimited amount of information about the datasets and processes behind AI models.
This issue touches on the balance between public transparency and the protection of proprietary business information.
While governments may seek greater insight into how AI systems are developed, companies argue that disclosure requirements must have clearly defined limits.
California’s position, meanwhile, rests on the need to give the public access to meaningful information about the material used to train generative AI systems.
A significant test for AI regulation
The case highlights a growing legal conflict between technology companies seeking to protect their development methods and governments attempting to establish stronger oversight of artificial intelligence.
The appeals court’s eventual decision could have implications beyond xAI, particularly for other AI developers operating under California’s transparency requirements.
For now, the judges have questioned both the constitutional objections raised by Musk’s company and the extent of the information California can require businesses to disclose.
The case, x.AI LLC v. Bonta, is pending before the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals under docket number 26-1591. The panel’s decision will determine whether xAI can secure an interim block on the law while its broader legal challenge continues.

