In a landmark pronouncement, the Supreme Court has resolutely articulated the necessity for chargesheets to embody unambiguous entries, delineating the precise role of each accused. The edict, delivered by a bench comprising Justices Sanjiv Khanna and SVN Bhatti, underscores the pivotal role of chargesheets in precipitating judicial cognizance.
The august court, cognizant of the pivotal role of chargesheets in legal adjudication, emphasized the indispensability of comprehensive documentation within these legal instruments. The chargesheet, according to the court’s dictate, ought to lucidly expound upon the delineation of roles undertaken by each accused, accompanied by a meticulous inventory of material evidence pertinent to the case.
Expressing disdain for the prevalent practice of perfunctory chargesheet filings devoid of substantive particulars, the court castigated instances where chargesheets merely echo the contours outlined in the First Information Report (FIR), without an elucidation on the evidentiary foundation.
While acknowledging that chargesheets need not assume the mantle of exhaustive treatises on evidence evaluation, the court advocated for a substantive exposition of the grounds underlying the alleged offence. Such elucidation, the court opined, would furnish magistrates with a cogent basis for determining the course of judicial action, be it the initiation of proceedings, issuance of notices, or framing of charges.
Furthermore, the court’s pronouncement invoked precedent, citing seminal judgments such as H.N. Rishbud and Inder Singh v. State of Delhi, which delineated the quintessential phases of a thorough investigation. Additionally, the court invoked recent jurisprudence, exemplified by Dablu Kujur v. State of Jharkhand, to underscore the imperative of strict adherence to procedural mandates, as enshrined in Section 173(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code.
In the wake of this pronouncement, legal practitioners and law enforcement agencies across the country are poised to recalibrate their procedural protocols, cognizant of the heightened imperative for transparency and meticulousness in chargesheet filings.
Loading...
Reload document 
Open in new tab 
